Can You Love Musicians?
This isn’t necessarily, as the title may imply, about whether you can fall in love with, date, marry and eventually spend your wrinkly days with a musician, however interesting such an article may be. Instead, this is about the idea of really loving, bordering on being obsessed with, the music of any particular artist. Is there one artist or band that you just love: they can do no wrong, the majority of their songs are masterpieces and you know you always love them, a belief so strong you are willing to tattoo it across you chest? I for one cannot.
Now this isn’t going to be an article ridiculing or criticising people who do ‘worship’ a particular artist or band. Frankly, there is absolutely nothing wrong with it and I really like the idea of loving an artist that much. However, I just have never experienced that passion. I certainly like a lot of bands across a lot of genres. A few of the artists and bands I particularly like at the moment are (not all necessarily new bands, but ones I’m still fond of listening to) The Research, Neon Plastix, We Are Scientists, Sufjan Stevens, The Teenagers, Final Fantasy, Late of the Pier and the remixes of Chewy Chocolate Cookies. I would not say though, that I love any of these bands intently. Even artists that I have listened to from an early age, such as Glassjaw, Mars Volta, Thursday and funk greats like Funkadelic, Gap Band, Average White Band, and who I still really like listening to, I would not say I am obsessed with.
I find there is always some little thing about them I don’t quite like, or I think that they do really good music but am not always in the mood to listen to that type of music, or they are too new and I want to see what their next album is like etc. There is always something to prevent me from declaring that I love that band without question and always will, that they are inspired, moving, sum me up perfectly, and so on.
However, after talking to my friend, an eternal Morrissey fan, about this briefly, I do not think that people who ‘love’ a particular artist are that different. She doesn’t like some of Morrissey’s songs anywhere near to others and listens to a vast array of other genres, some that are quite significantly different to the likes of Morrissey. So, arguably, she views Morrissey in a similar way to how I view the artists I really like. The difference, though, is that she will defend Morrissey to the end and has a passion to be envied when discussing anything to do with him. And when she meets others with this same passion for Morrissey (and there are many, even in the quite town of Egham), an instant bond is created. Loving Morrissey like this can actually be enough foundation for an entire friendship.
And Morrissey is just one example. I know plenty of other people who love a certain artist or band in the same way as my friend, which makes me question: why not me? Why do I not feel that passion for a particular artist? I believe I feel that passion about music in general, as you may notice by the general musical focus of my posts, but I have never really experienced that passion about one artist in particular.
So what do you think about this passion and why is it so elusive? Is there an artist you love? Perhaps it is a matter of dedication and I am just too lazy. Or perhaps my time is yet to come. Sometime in the future I will shout down anyone who says something against a particular artist and realise that I too have become one of the worshippers.
thegreatsaundini said,
March 15, 2008 at 1:36 pm
I think there is a distinct difference between worship and just liking music too. I really love the Feeling’s Twelve Stops from Home, particularly as the music holds so much sentimental value for me because it’s attached itself to the feelings I had when I first started going out with my fiancee. However, fandom is a different beast entirely. I just find it really perplexing personally, the autograph hunting, the buying the merchandise etc. I just can’t get over the fact that the musicians are never so different from you or me.
I suppose, music and fandom alike is part of our identity as human beings. But just because you don’t find that in music doesn’t mean that there is nothing. If we belong to any same group then that’s something which brings you together. Being a Christian for instance automatically gives me something in common with other Christians. I suppose we become disciples of a principle and then journey in it together.
oxygenchameleon said,
April 12, 2008 at 5:54 pm
I love[d]?? Coldplay [sortof odd, i suppose, since many consider them pretty Middle of the Road and therefore may wonder how they can create such strong responses from people]… I’d say I was obsessed with them a few years ago – crying at being unable to attend the X&Y album launch party cos i had a Mechanics exam the next day would probably attest to this.
And yet now, whilst I hardly ever listen to them, whenever shuffle does chance upon one of their songs, I recognise just how much I still love their music, despite my own tastes having shifted and evolved, as expected, I can still count on Coldplay to give me depth in musical experience.
Although I’d still say they’re my favourite band.. maybe because I think I’ve lost that kindof obsessive nature over music in general… sometimes i feel guilty in holding this statement, as though it is now false because of the fact that i have listened to maybe 5coldplay songs in total in the past few months. But i guess frequency and active participation isn’t a requisite. If you can still love someone, having not seen them due to distance or whatever for a significant period of time, then why not still love a musician?
I think it’s about frame of mind and approach. Irrational love of a band or artist, for me at least, could only have happened at that age – the few years before and during 6th form. For others it may be different. x
thegreatsaundini said,
April 21, 2008 at 9:50 pm
Wow. Mechanics! I never knew you were a mathematician Reda. Good on you.
oxygenchameleon said,
April 22, 2008 at 2:40 pm
Haha, yeah …i took A-Level Maths and AS Physics. Who woulda thunk?